A burrito can be a healthy meal, and it can also be a very heavy one. It comes down to what goes inside, what goes on top, and how much of it you eat in one sitting. Beans or lean meat, some vegetables and a tortilla make a filling, balanced meal for a lot of people. Add a pile of cheese, sour cream and a blanket of chili and you have something richer that most of us treat as a treat. So the honest answer to “are burritos healthy” is that you get to decide, mostly by how you order.
We have been rolling burritos at the same address in Aurora since 1991, and it’s a fair question to ask about any food you love. Some folks are watching what they eat, some are training for something, and some just want to feel good after lunch instead of needing a nap. Here is how we think about it, and how to order one of our burritos so it fits whatever you’re aiming for.
What makes a burrito healthy or not?
Start with the parts. A burrito is a flour tortilla wrapped around a filling, and if you’re curious where that definition starts and stops, we wrote a whole piece on what makes a burrito a burrito. Each part brings something different.
The tortilla is mostly refined flour. It gives you energy without much fiber, and it’s also what holds everything together, so a burrito without one is really a bowl. The filling is where most of the nutrition lives. Beans bring fiber and plant protein. Meat brings protein, and how much fat comes along with it depends on the cut and how it’s cooked. Cheese adds protein and a lot of flavor, along with saturated fat and salt. Sour cream adds richness. Guacamole adds richness too, though the fat in avocado is the kind most nutrition advice is friendly toward.
Then there’s the outside. A smothered burrito sits under chili and melted cheese, which is wonderful and also adds up quickly. Portion matters as much as anything. A big burrito can easily be two meals, and nobody says you have to finish it in one go. Wrapping up half for later is one of the simplest health moves there is.
Salt is the other thing worth knowing about. Restaurant food in general tends to run higher in sodium than what most people cook at home, and Mexican food with cheese, chili and seasoned meat is no exception. If you’ve been told to watch your sodium, that’s a good reason to keep the toppings simple and get the chili on the side so you control how much you use.
Bean or beef: which burrito filling is the lighter choice?
Our burrito menu lists bean, beef, beef and bean, chicken, carnitas, carne asada, Philly cheesesteak and the Mexican Hamburger. If you want the lightest option, the bean burrito is a good place to start. Our beans are made in the pot, and beans in general are one of the better things you can put on a plate. They’re filling, high in fiber and a decent source of protein, which is why they keep showing up in just about every healthy eating guide.
Beef brings more protein and more fat. A beef burrito is a hearty, satisfying meal, and there’s nothing wrong with it, but if you’re comparing the two side by side, bean is the lighter pick. The beef and bean burrito lands in the middle and gives you some of each.
Chicken is generally leaner than beef, so a chicken burrito is a good choice if you want plenty of protein without as much fat. The carne asada burrito is another strong option. Our carne asada is thin strips of steak grilled with jalapeños, onions and tomatoes, so you get some vegetables cooked right in with the meat. Carnitas, Philly cheesesteak and the Mexican Hamburger are on the richer end. They’re the ones to order on the days you’re eating for joy and not keeping score.
How do our five burrito styles compare?
This is where you have the most control. Every burrito on our menu can be ordered five ways, and the style you pick changes the meal more than almost anything else.
Plain means no chili or cheese inside, just the tortilla and the filling. It’s the simplest and lightest version of any burrito we make.
Chili means green chili inside the burrito. You get the flavor we’re known for without the extra cheese, and a little green chili goes a long way.
Special means green chili and cheese inside. It’s richer than Chili, but everything is still wrapped up neatly, which makes it easy to eat on the go.
Smothered means the burrito is covered with green chili and cheese. This is the classic, the one most people picture when they think of a Colorado style burrito. It’s also the most generous with chili and cheese, so it’s the heaviest of the first four.
Deluxe is smothered, then topped with lettuce and tomatoes. The fresh vegetables are a nice touch, but Deluxe still includes everything that comes with Smothered, so think of it as the fullest plate of the five.
How to order a burrito at El Chubby’s to fit your goals
Everything we make is made to order, and almost anything can be prepared the way you like. That’s good news if you’re trying to eat a certain way, because you can simply ask. Here are a few ways to put that to work.
For a lighter lunch, try a bean or chicken burrito ordered Plain or Chili, and ask for green chili on the side. That way you can spoon on as much or as little as you want instead of having the whole portion poured over the top. We offer three chilis, hot green, mild green and red, so you can still have the flavor you came for. You can also grab extra chili on its own from our sides menu, anywhere from a side to a quart, if you’d rather control portions at home.
If you’re after protein, a carne asada or chicken burrito ordered Plain or Chili gives you plenty of it. Skip the extras you don’t miss, like a side of sour cream. If cheese matters to you, keep it and let something else go. Small trades like that add up without making the meal feel like a punishment.
If you’re going all in, go all in. A smothered or deluxe beef and bean burrito under hot green chili is one of the best things we make, and food is supposed to be enjoyed. Eat half, take the other half home, and you’ve turned one burrito into two good meals.
Mornings work the same way. Our breakfast burritos start with egg and come with fillings like bean, potato, bacon, ham, chorizo, sausage or steak. Egg with bean or egg with diced ham is a lighter start than potato and chorizo, and asking for chili on the side works at breakfast too.
If you’d like more general ideas beyond burritos, we put together a guide on how to eat healthy at a Mexican restaurant that covers tacos, plates and sides as well.
So, is a burrito a healthy choice?
It can be. A burrito built around beans or lean meat, with the chili and cheese kept in proportion, is a satisfying meal that will carry you through the afternoon. A smothered, cheese-heavy burrito is a richer meal that most people enjoy now and then. Neither one is wrong. What matters is that you know the difference and order the one that fits your day.
A few habits help no matter what you order. Pick the filling first, since that’s where the nutrition is. Choose your style on purpose, knowing that Plain and Chili are lighter and Smothered and Deluxe are heavier. Ask for chili on the side when you want to control the amount. And don’t be shy about taking half home.
If you have a specific diet or health condition, your doctor or a dietitian is the right person to set your targets. Our job is to make the food and make it the way you ask for it, and we’re happy to do that. Stop by 1191 S Abilene St and order at the counter or the drive-thru, or order online for pickup or delivery and build your burrito exactly the way you want it.

